Private equity for the individual investor: Can co-investment bridge the gap?

Amid shifts in the private capital market, the prospect of co-investment is presenting an alternative gateway into private equity and venture capital

Historically, private markets have been restricted to large institutions, pension funds and high-net-worth individuals, with the capital requirements, specialist knowledge and long investment horizons often presenting significant barriers to entry for smaller investors.

Amid shifts in the private capital market, the prospect of co-investment is presenting an alternative gateway into private equity and venture capital. It allows investors to directly participate in individual deals alongside General Partners, widening access to opportunities over how private capital is assessed and distributed.

Yet, while the prospect of investing alongside experienced private equity and venture capital firms is an attractive one, uncertainty remains over just how accessible these opportunities actually are. Eligibility requirements, minimum investment thresholds and the rigid nature of private market assets can continue to exclude large sections of the investing public.

As interest in private equity evolves, co-investment presents an opportunity to reconsider who can get access to private capital, but does it necessarily represent genuine democratisation, or simply a new route into an otherwise exclusive investment landscape?

Understanding the co-investment model

Co-investment is not a new concept for the private equity and venture capital sectors, though its traditional use has had a far wider reach for institutional investors or areas where substantial capital commitments have been more accessible.

Essentially, the model allows investors to participate alongside one another in the same company or investment opportunity, often with an established investment firm responsible for sourcing and assessing the deal.

The structure can take different forms, though the underlying principle is that investors gain exposure to an individual investment alongside another investor or established GP, rather than investing solely through a collective fund. In turn, this can offer investors greater discretion over which opportunities they choose to pursue, although the level of choice is relative to the structure of the investment.

As Millie Haigh, investor relations director of Growth Capital Ventures (GCV) explains, traditionally funds generally involve committing capital to a manager, who then makes investment decisions on behalf of investors and constructs a portfolio around a predetermined strategy.

By contrast, a deal-by-deal approach can allow investors to assess individual opportunities and decide which businesses they want to support, while also benefiting from the expertise and financial due diligence of an experienced investment team.

The way co-investment opportunities are assessed can also vary between firms. Peter Knight, who leads co-investment opportunities at Connection Capital, explains that historically co-investment programmes tend to be developed in a “sponsor-led approach”, placing considerable emphasis on the firm’s existing relationship with their GP. Connection Capital, by contrast, takes a more “asset-led approach.”

As Knight continues, “we evaluate opportunities through much the same lens as a direct investor, focusing on the quality of the business, its management team, market positioning, earnings and growth prospects, but we also spend considerable time examining transaction structures, including leverage, capital structure, shareholder rights and the balance of risk and reward.”

The distinction between these structures is also explored in academic research into private equity investment, ‘adverse selection and the performance of private equity co-investments’ (2020). It describes how traditional funds typically operate as limited partnerships, with investors committing capital to a manager who is responsible for selecting and managing the underlying investments.

Co-investments, meanwhile, provide investors with the prospect of participating in individual portfolio company transactions alongside a fund manager. While both approaches have their merits, the distinction shows how different investment structures can influence the level of involvement investors have in allocating their capital.

Why are individual investors looking to private markets?

The appeal of private markets extends beyond the prospect of financial returns for individual investors. Gaining access to early-stage and high-growth businesses can offer an opportunity to participate in companies that might not yet be available through public markets, while also allowing investors to support businesses and sectors they believe have potential.

As Haigh explains, “there’s something appealing about being able to invest in businesses and sectors you know or have a particular interest in. For some investors, it’s not just about the potential financial return, but also the opportunity to back innovative companies and be part of their growth.”

Co-investment can also provide opportunities to develop closer relationships with private equity and venture capital managers, offering insight into how investment opportunities are identified, assessed and managed over time.

Knight argues that the relationship-building aspect is often overlooked, particularly for investors who also make commitments to a fund manager. By investing alongside a manager, individuals can gain a better understanding of how they operate throughout the investment lifecycle, right from the deal execution through the holding period to the eventual exit from the investment.

Tax incentives, particularly across the UK, provide additional motivation, particularly through the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) and Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS), which offer tax relief on qualifying investments. However, these incentives should be viewed as an additional benefit rather than an alternative for assessing the business and the risks associated. Moreover, early-stage investments remain high-risk and investors could lose their capital.

Access to expertise, not just opportunity

For individual investors, sourcing deal flow often presents a challenge, particularly as opportunities are typically accessed through established networks and existing relationships within the sector.

GPs, therefore, can provide another route into opportunities for investors who may otherwise struggle to gain access, drawing from their ability to utilise existing industry connections. However, gaining access to opportunity coincides with added responsibility, which presents an obstacle for individual investors without specialist knowledge or extensive resources.

As Haigh says: “There’s a considerable amount of work involved in assessing an investment properly, from financial analysis and due diligence through to valuation, deal structuring and understanding the company’s growth plans and the risks involved."

“An experienced investment firm has the people and processes in place to undertake that work, giving investors access to opportunities that have already been through a structured assessment.”

However, professional due diligence doesn’t automatically mean relying solely on the assessment carried out by the firm. As Knight explains “co-investors typically become involved after the sponsor has commissioned much of the commercial, financial, legal and other specialist due diligence.

“Our role is therefore generally less about determining its scope and more about critically reviewing the findings and incorporating them into our own investment assessment.”

Nevertheless, any amount of access to professional expertise does not eliminate the risks associated with private-market investment. Whilst the support of a firm can act as a guidance post, the performance of individual businesses will always remain uncertain, and therefore responsibility ultimately lies with the investor itself who retains the risk of losing capital.

Choice versus control

“I think the biggest difference is the control investors have over which businesses they invest in,” Haigh continues. In this context, that control relates to the choice of where capital is allocated, as opposed to having influence over the businesses themselves.

Unlike traditional private-market funds, where investors typically rely on a manager to select investments on their behalf, certain co-investment structures allow individuals to construct portfolios around their own objectives, allowing them to be highly selective. As Knight puts it “unlike traditional discretionary funds, co-investors can assess individual opportunities and construct portfolios with much greater precision.”

Greater choice over investment can also allow individuals to construct portfolios around their own objectives, allowing them to be highly selective. As Knight puts it “unlike traditional blind-pool funds, co-investors can assess individual opportunities and construct portfolios with much greater precision.”

Therefore, they don’t need to fund an entire acquisition themselves, “by participating in a co-investment syndicate, investors can access individual assets without committing all the capital required.

“Co-investment therefore combines some of the most attractive characteristics of direct and fund investing: individual asset selection, specialist third-party expertise and participation in larger transactions with relatively modest capital commitments,” Knight added.

That said, the freedom around making said choices also places greater importance on the information available to investors. When considering individual private-market opportunities, investors need to know how a business is performing, what areas are successful and what barriers they are facing to achieve its value creation plans.

For providers like Growth Capital Ventures and other firms within the sector, keeping investors informed is an essential part of the co-investment process, as Haigh explains that “transparency must go beyond the initial investment. Investors want to know how a business is performing, what’s going well, what challenges it’s facing and how it’s progressing against its plans.”

This consistency in communication can give investors greater visibility over how the business they have backed is performing, including any developments that may influence their investment. It might not provide them with influence over company decisions, but it can help individuals maintain a clear understanding of how their capital is being deployed and managed.

Ultimately, greater transparency makes for more informed investment decisions, but access to information should not be confused with having control over the underlying business. Investors may get a say which opportunities they participate in, but the responsibility for managing and directing those lies elsewhere. While co-investment can provide individuals with greater involvement in allocating their capital, they must still rely on the investment firm’s expertise and the company’s management to deliver on its growth strategy.

How accessible is private capital, really?

Access to private markets has evolved considerably in recent years, with an increasing range of investment platforms, private banks and wealth managers creating alternative routes into private equity and venture capital.

Historically, they have been largely relationship-driven and accessible to larger-scale investors. “Co-investment has contributed to this evolution, although it is only one part of a much broader trend”, Knight explains, as he emphasises a significant shift in private wealth access in the past five to 10 years.

How accessible these alternative routes into private equity and venture capital are, remains dependent on several factors. Limitations continue to prevail as to who can participate, due to minimum investment thresholds, eligibility requirements and the risks associated with private assets.

One of the most immediate barriers remains the amount of capital required to participate. While some co-investment providers have sought to lower entry thresholds, the sums involved can still represent a significant commitment for individual investors. For example, Haigh explains that GCV has sought to make opportunities available to investors with commitments starting from £5,000 or £10,000 depending on the investment.

While this does offer a lower entry point than the substantial commitments traditionally associated with private markets investment, it does not necessarily make these opportunities accessible to the wider investing public. For many, committing thousands of pounds to an illiquid, high-risk investment may still remain financially unrealistic.

Beyond the initial financial commitment, eligibility and investor suitability also determine who can participate. As Haigh continues, “investors need to have the knowledge, experience and financial capacity to understand the risks they’re taking.” Early-stage investments remain high-risk and often involve having capital tied up for years.

Knight argues that evaluating an individual private company requires a different level of understanding from selecting a fund manager to manage a diversified investment strategy. Therefore, his view is that individual co-investments are really only suitable for high-net-worth and sophisticated investors, and that investor sophistication is one of the principal barriers to broader participation.

As Haigh explains, “The aim should not necessarily be to make every private market investment available to everyone. It’s about giving suitable investors better access to opportunities, along with the information they need to make their own decisions.”

Ultimately co-investment may be helping to broaden participation in private markets, but greater access doesn’t necessarily correspond to universal accessibility. While new investment structures continue to create additional opportunities for individuals to participate alongside established firms, financial commitments, eligibility requirements and the risks associated with private assets still prove to be significant barriers.

Whether co-investment can genuinely democratise private capital will therefore depend not simply on how many investors can enter the market, but on whether participation becomes accessible and sustainable for a wider range of individuals.

Previous Post

ICG Europe backs employee-owned Churchill Group as it acquires Principle Cleaning

Next Post
Zoe Clements smiles wearing black-rimmed glasses and a black jacket against a plain grey background.

BGF appoints Zoe Clements as non-executive director